Kathy Bennett
2 months ago
"Poly Perfect Seasons. It is a great company. It's so easy to work with them. Besides them doing a wonderful job, I can text the owner and get a reply immediately and someone comes out the same day if…"

Clayton, IN · New Water Heater Installation
Polley's Perfect Seasons installs new tank and tankless water heaters across Clayton, Stilesville, Belleville, and Hazelwood. Fast swaps on most standard tanks, expert sizing for well-water and propane homes, and 0% financing for 18 months. Call (317) 839-8800.

NATE-Certified
ACCA MemberWhat's included
Well-fed Clayton-area homes often have lower static pressure than city water. We size flow rate and BTU correctly on tankless so showers don't go cold.
Propane Rinnai installs in Stilesville and Hazelwood are routine for us - we handle the gas-line resize, regulator, and combustion air requirements.
Many older Clayton homes have water heaters in hall closets or crawlspaces. We bring the right venting, drip pans, and clearance solutions.
If you call before noon, most standard 40-50 gallon tank swaps finish quickly. Call (317) 839-8800 first thing for the fastest turnaround.
Neighborhoods served
Outside this list? Call (317) 839-8800 - we dispatch the full 20-mile Clayton radius daily.
From the field
Every photo below is a real job by Polley's Perfect Seasons technicians in Hendricks County, IN. No stock images, no AI renders - actual installs and repairs from the trucks rolling out of our shop.






Our process
No mystery, no upsells, no surprises. Here's exactly what happens from the time you call (317) 839-8800 to the time we leave your driveway.
Tank-for-tank swaps can usually be quoted over the phone (we just need the gallon size, fuel type, and a quick photo of the install). Tankless upgrades or layout changes get a free in-home walkthrough first.
We size by household occupancy, fixture count, and (on tankless) incoming groundwater temperature - Clayton-area well water runs colder year-round and needs a higher BTU rating to deliver the same hot output.
Floor runners, drip pan installed if required, expansion tank sized for the new heater, T&P routed correctly, isolation valves added for future service, and on tankless: dedicated electrical, descaling ports, and code-compliant intake/exhaust.
Recovery temperature verified, gas pressure tested at the burner, leak check on every connection, and the manufacturer warranty registered before we leave. You get a digital photo set of the finished install for your records.
Pricing transparency
Every quote is written, itemized, and given before any work starts. No call-out fees that vanish if you decline. No surprise add-ons. Here's the honest pricing reality for our Clayton-area customers.
Most 40–50 gallon tank-for-tank swaps in Clayton-area homes run $1,800–$3,200 installed including new T&P, expansion tank, shutoff, and old-tank haul-away.
Indoor Rinnai installs typically run $4,500–$7,500 depending on gas-line sizing and venting route. Tax credits and longer warranty often justify the upfront premium.
Tankless and high-efficiency upgrades qualify for zero-interest financing for 18 months. Paperless application, fast approval in most cases.
Clayton-area knowledge
A new water heater in a Clayton-area home is a sizing problem before it's a brand problem. Most of western Hendricks County is on private wells, which means incoming water can run as cold as 48°F in February - about 15°F colder than the Indianapolis city-water average. A tankless unit sized for city water will dribble lukewarm water in a January Stilesville shower; a properly sized Rinnai for the same home needs more BTUs to make up the difference. Propane homes have a second sizing layer: the existing regulator and gas line might be fine for the old 40-gallon tank but undersized for a new tankless or a 75-gallon tank - we check the fuel system at quote, not at install. Tight closet and crawlspace installs (very common on 1970s–1980s Clayton ranches) need low-profile units, sometimes a powervent option, and a real drip pan with a routed drain. The right install isn't always the same brand or size as the one coming out - it's the one matched to your water, your fuel, and your floor plan.
FAQ
Quick answers Clayton-area homeowners ask before calling (317) 839-8800.
More Clayton services
Same shop on Iowa St, same family-owned team, same 12-year warranty. Whatever's broken or due for an upgrade, it's all one phone call - (317) 839-8800.
Fast no-cool dispatch from our Iowa St shop.
View pageDaikin Fit, every brand, 12-year parts & labor.
View page27-point spring tune-up. Catches failures early.
View page24/7 no-heat - gas, propane, every brand.
View pageRight-sized gas, propane, and 96% AFUE installs.
View pageFall furnace tune-up. CO test included.
View pageTank + tankless. Well-water expertise.
View pageReviews
Based on 169+ Plainfield reviews
Stack any of these with your service call - no coupons, no fine-print games.
No interest, no payments for 18 months on qualifying installs. New systems as low as $90/month.
Save $1,100 instantly on a Daikin Fit System - quiet, compact, and built for Indiana weather.
Active or retired military, veterans, first responders, and educators save 10% on every service.
Real Clayton technicians answering 24/7. Fast service most days, 12-year guarantee on every install.
Or visit us: 4870 Iowa St, Clayton, IN 46118 - walk-ins welcome.